← Catalog

HT-RES-WA-tacoma-chinese-reconciliation — A community expelled, a city asked to remember

Tacoma, Washington · Reflection stopnearest public groundPublished researchLaborEducation

Where you go

1741 N. Schuster Parkway, Tacoma, WA 98403 [1,5] nearest public ground

The visitable anchor as named in the dossier's locator record (printed address). The Before you go section below says where you may stand — a historic pin is not a public entrance.

Before you go

Public commemorative park, not an expulsion-site exploration or scavenger hunt. The Foundation and City identify the park at 1741 N. Schuster Parkway, Tacoma, WA 98403. The Foundation explicitly welcomes visitors to the interpretive paths. [1–2]

Hours evidence: The current City-linked municipal code, §8.27.220, sets the general park window at 30 minutes before sunrise until 30 minutes after sunset, subject to different posted or director-established hours. This is the verified general rule, not a photographed current park sign or same-day opening confirmation. Use daylight and obey posted restrictions. Conflicting third-party fixed-hour listings are not adopted. The old City Title 8 PDF now directs readers to eCode; the superseded PDF is not treated as current law. [3–4]

November weather, path condition, closure notices at the entrance and exact accessible circulation have not been field-checked. Parks Tacoma lists ADA parking and soft trail features at Fuzhou Ting; that is not a guarantee that every interpretive path is step-free. Restroom availability is not confirmed. Pavilion bookings can limit its use; Parks Tacoma manages rentals, not evidence of unrestricted access to a private ceremony. [5]

No visit, reservation, contact or route activation performed.

This is reflection ground. Read and witness. There are no finds, no tags, and no scoring here.

The story

On November 3, 1885, Tacoma's Chinese residents were forcibly expelled by an organized white mob that included civic leaders. The park's own history describes people driven out and buildings subsequently burned, but its framing of a supposedly orderly method must not be mistaken for absence of harm. Families, livelihoods and community were attacked. [6]

Listen first to an expelled resident: Lum May's sworn account, dated June 3, 1886, describes ten years of Tacoma business selling provisions, medicine and general merchandise. His short sentence “I asked General Sprague and other Citizens of Tacoma for protection” restores a person's request for safety, rather than centering the perpetrators' self-description. The published transcription also records forced removal of his wife. This is testimony, not a modern medical diagnosis. [7]

Kwok Sue's account describes merchandise and labor contracting, destroyed records and losses he could not fully document. Sing Lee explicitly distinguishes what he learned from others from what he personally witnessed: he was away when his family was expelled. Their differing vantage points must remain visible. [7]

The university project's source index identifies the originals as Miscellaneous Letters of the Department of State, 1789–1906, NARA M-179, Roll 707. Six scanned affidavits and a transcription are published. The transcript was read; the Lum May scan was located but not fully visually collated. Do not describe this as an independently checked diplomatic original. [8–9]

Reconciliation is also labor: the City's chronology names Dr. and Mrs. David Murdock's 1991 citizen request, a 1992 advisory committee, and Resolution 32415 of November 30, 1993. These are modern actions to confront the record, not a claim that the harm has been undone. [10]

Then / now

Then: Chinese households and businesses occupied several parts of Tacoma; the expulsion and destruction were not confined to a single modern park parcel. [6–7]

Now: This is a deliberately created landscape for historical interpretation and reconciliation. The City describes the former National Guard property as near the early Chinese settlement, not as a preserved cluster of original Chinese homes. The Fuzhou Ting is a modern gift from Tacoma's sister city, not a surviving 1885 structure. [5,11]

The Foundation continues public anti-racist commemoration. Its October 24, 2026 walk announcement describes a symbolic reversal of the expulsion. That dated event is not a standing invitation to retrace an unverified historical route, cross rail ground, or join an event after it has ended. [12]

What's still there

  • Public park: Open interpretive paths and permitted visitor areas, subject to actual signs and conditions. [1–4]
  • Commemorative features: Garden landscape, stone tableaux and pavilion. Interpretive construction is distinct from original expulsion remains. [1,5]
  • Pavilion during events: Respect reservations and private ceremonies; no photographing participants as historical subjects. [5]
  • Railway, shore works and adjoining transportation ground: Not public visitor permission. Do not cross tracks or improvise a shortcut to a historic map location.
  • Historic community locations: Archival context only in this dossier. No legal public approach to individual former homes, wharves or expulsion endpoints established.
  • Unbuilt features: A master plan is not an as-built inventory. The City's project archive still distinguishes completed phases from unfunded Phase IV. [2]

Permanent entrance rule: a historic road or district pin is not a public entrance. Enter only through a currently authorized public park approach. An archive coordinate cannot authorize access.

The stop, step by step

Reflection sequence within an open public park, not a mapped route:

  1. At the authorized entrance, read the welcome and understand why this landscape exists. Do not begin with a photo challenge.
  2. Use open interpretive paths to encounter the community's work and ordinary lives before reading about their forced removal.
  3. Read the short Lum May testimony excerpt with its source label. Allow silence; do not reenact an expulsion or ask visitors to role-play victims.
  4. Compare the modern city's acknowledgment with the older failure of protection.
  5. Strongest ending: At a permitted quiet public place, consider the request for protection and what responsibility the present community accepts. This is an editorial reflection prompt, not a claimed authentic standing location for Lum May.

If closed or unsafe, read the published testimony remotely. Nothing is collected, scored, unlocked or hunted.

Locator record

Stable name
Tacoma Chinese Reconciliation Park
Printed address
1741 N. Schuster Parkway, Tacoma, WA 98403 [1,5]
Operator
— blank in the record
NRHP / National Register
— blank in the record
HMdb
269602
ARK
— blank in the record
Archive ID
NARA M-179, Roll 707, Miscellaneous Letters of the Department of State, 1789–1906; individual item identifier unverified [8]
Register URL
— blank in the record
Coordinates
47, 122
Coordinate source
HMdb 269602, printed coordinates [13]; not converted or geocoded
State / county / city
Washington / Pierce / Tacoma
Exact authorized entrance coordinates
— blank in the record
CFR/specification
No federal site-specific specification established; local visitor hours TMC §8.27.220 [3]
Owner/operator
City of Tacoma; reconciliation project partner Chinese Reconciliation Project Foundation; Fuzhou Ting rentals managed by Parks Tacoma [2,5]
Access status
Public commemorative park under posted rules; no adjoining historic-site or rail access established
Record status
DRAFTED, awaiting QC; reflection only; no upload, publication, outreach or route activation

See the recorded point on OpenStreetMap — the point as printed in the dossier's locator record. A pin is not a public entrance; the Before you go section above says where you may stand.

Blank fields are blank in the source dossier. Nothing is invented to fill them.

Honest gaps & disagreements

  • Numbers: The Foundation synopsis says roughly 200 people remained to be driven out. Testimony gives larger estimates of Chinese residents in and around Tacoma. Different estimates and scopes must not become a falsely precise single count. [6–7]
  • Fire dates: The synopsis places burning the next day; the affidavit transcription contains November 5 and November 6 references. Preserve this discrepancy pending original-document collation; do not conflate distinct fires. [6–7]
  • Transcription quality: The compilation contains omissions and apparent typographical/date errors. It is a research entry point, not a critical edition. No complete property-loss inventory reconstructed. [7]
  • Construction dates: City 2015 fact sheet says Phase III finished September 2015; current project archive gives 2016. These may refer to different completion stages, but that explanation is unverified. [2,11]
  • Hours: General code verified; current site-specific posted exceptions and same-day conditions remain unverified. [3]
  • Location: HMdb's marker-address approximation differs from the operator park address. Do not substitute a marker geocode for the visitor entrance. [1,13]
  • Tribal context: This dossier does not supply a researched Puyallup first-person account or site-specific Tribal history. Do not invent one or frame Chinese community history as the beginning of habitation here.

Save & note

Checking your sign-in…

Photo record (from the dossier)

Modern interpretive record: HMdb 269602, “Welcome to the Tacoma Chinese Reconciliation Park,” photographs 1 and 2, Ian Lefkowitz, October 18, 2023. The catalog describes the sign next to wayfinding at an entrance. It is a dated contributed marker record, not a verified current entrance survey. Photographs themselves not field-matched. Photographer credit is not a reuse license; rights clearance remains blank. [13]

Historical document facsimile: Lum May affidavit, eight-page scan [9], catalog provenance NARA M-179 Roll 707 [8]. Scan located; no individual NARA item identifier or reproduction license established. This is a document-image lead, not a period photograph of the expulsion.

No authenticated historic street-camera station, original community-house image accession or matched then/now viewpoint established.

  • Photo Point (APPROXIMATE):
  • Verified camera coordinates:
  • Image reuse permission:
  • Field comparison status: NOT VERIFIED
Records & sources
  1. Foundation visitor description: https://tacomachinesepark.org/about-the-tacoma-chinese-garden-and-reconciliation-park/
  2. City project archive, Chinese Reconciliation Park section: https://tacoma.gov/government/departments/planning-and-development-services/long-range-strategic-plans/project-archive/
  3. Current linked municipal Park Code, §8.27.220: https://ecode360.com/48389255
  4. City Clerk April 2026 Title 8 migration notice: https://cms.tacoma.gov/cityclerk/Files/MunicipalCode/Title08-PublicSafety.pdf
  5. Parks Tacoma Fuzhou Ting visitor/rental record: https://www.parkstacoma.gov/place/fuzhou-ting/
  6. Foundation historical synopsis: https://tacomachinesepark.org/tacoma-chinese-park/expulsion-the-tacoma-method/
  7. Cesare Bigolin, published affidavit transcriptions; Lum May PDF pp. 3–5, Kwok Sue pp. 6–8, Sing Lee p. 9 onward: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5908c05829687f9e7e18ee9c/t/5920957a1e5b6c6e5a8796e5/1495307643296/ChineseAffidavitsTranscripts.pdf
  8. The Tacoma Method primary-source index and archive provenance: https://www.tacomamethod.com/resources
  9. Lum May affidavit facsimile: https://www.tacomamethod.com/s/LumMayAffidavit.pdf
  10. City project chronology, updated March 14, 2019: https://cms.cityoftacoma.org/Planning/Chinese%20Reconciliation%20Park/Documents/Chinese%20Reconciliation%20Park%20Project%20Chronology%20%283-14-19%29.pdf
  11. City/Foundation September 2015 fact sheet: https://cms.cityoftacoma.org/Planning/Chinese%20Reconciliation%20Park/Documents/Chinese%20Park%20Fact%20Sheet%20and%20Site%20Plan%209-24-15%20bilingual.pdf
  12. Foundation 2026 walk announcement, not current access authorization: https://crpftacoma.org/crpf-news/2026-walk-for-reconciliation-against-racism/
  13. HMdb marker metadata, not operator authority: https://www.hmdb.org/m.asp?m=269602

Published research — the record, with its gaps printed. Not yet field-proven.