← Catalog

Honey Springs — who comes home

Oklahoma · Reflection stopdrive-upPublished researchMilitaryMiningLaborRailroad

Where you go

Oklahoma — point recorded in the dossier drive-up

The visitable anchor as named in the dossier's locator record (recorded point). The Before you go section below says where you may stand — a historic pin is not a public entrance.

Before you go

Staffed Honey Springs visitor center only, Tue–Sat 9–4:30 Central, admission. Closed Nov. 26–28 and Dec. 24–25, 2026. Quiet reflection. Defer travel in unsafe weather or when the center is closed. Checked Nov. 19 Pacific [1].

This is reflection ground. Read and witness. There are no finds, no tags, and no scoring here.

The story

People caught between armies

Cherokee Nation’s public history records Cherokee and Creek regiments on both sides at Honey Springs, with the 1st Kansas Colored Volunteer Infantry also engaged. Mvskoke Media records that the battle took place at a settlement in the Muscogee Nation. It describes the Civil War’s divisions within communities and families and reports the Nation’s recognition of the battlefield as a Traditional Cultural Property. These sources provide the setting for the military reports. The reports record units and losses, and the Nation’s history explains why those names belong to communities for whom the history continues. [2–3]

Honey Springs also served as a Confederate supply point in the fight over Fort Gibson. The Oklahoma Historical Society reconstructs the long supply line from Fort Scott and the pressure on it. On July 17, 1863, troops fought around Elk Creek and the Honey Springs settlement. Read the visitors’ center account with the official reports in view. An officer recording events after a fight could see only part of what was happening. [4–5]

What the officers could see

Union Lt. Col. John Bowles reported for the 1st Kansas Colored Infantry on July 20. He recorded that he was “partly shut out from view of the left by the thick brush” and initially could not see that Col. James M. Williams had fallen wounded. In the same report he credited his regiment’s men and officers for their conduct. The regiment has a nineteenth-century designation quoted only as printed by the records. Bowles’s report is an officer’s account. Individual Black enlisted men’s own testimonies remain to be found. [5]

Confederate Brig. Gen. Douglas H. Cooper wrote from near the Canadian in August. He recorded the retreat and credited the troops under Col. D. N. McIntosh with contributing to “the safe retreat of the train and brigade.” He also named Lt. A. G. Ballenger of the Second Cherokee Regiment among those killed. Cooper’s claim about what caused his defeat and his strengths and casualty estimates are his own. The reports do not resolve one another by averaging their numbers. [4–5]

The deaths before the battle

Union Lt. Col. Fred. W. Schaurte’s report places three losses at the Arkansas River crossing before the engagement. He prints Huston Mayfield, Key Dougherty and To-cah-le-ges-kie. The transcription varies in the last man's spelling across the body and the return. His name and those of the other two belong in the reading because a battle headline does not tell readers where every family’s loss fell. [5]

Then / now

  • Historic location. Honey Springs settlement, supply depot and Elk Creek battle landscape. It includes sensitive places linked to the armies’ casualties. Only the staffed visitor center is a physical anchor in this dossier. [1–5]
  • Lawful physical anchor. Honey Springs Battlefield visitor center at 423159 E 1030 Road, Checotah postal address. OHS describes the signed approach east of US-69 off Gertrude Avenue. Drive up to posted public arrival and make the short walk to the entrance. Remain in the galleries and authorized entry area. [1]
  • Weather fallback. The records can be read remotely if the visitor center closes or travel conditions are unsafe. [1,5]

What's still there

FeatureAccess
Honey Springs visitor center exhibitsPublic interior during regular staffed hours.
Battlefield landscape, Texas Road remnant and Elk CreekHistoric ground interpreted by the operator. The staffed center is the scope of this draft.
Possible unmarked burials and sensitive groundAccess excluded from this itinerary. No mapped burial positions.
1863 supply structuresSurviving fabric not verified for the public anchor.

[1,3–5]

The stop, step by step

  1. Start in the public galleries with the Nations’ perspective on the divided communities. [1–3]
  2. Read Bowles on his limited field of vision and Cooper on the retreat. Give each account its own attribution. [4–5]
  3. Strongest story moment — The men who never reached Elk Creek. Read the three names in Schaurte’s report from a quiet spot in the visitor center. Pause before reading the casualty totals. [1,5]

Locator record

Stable name
Honey Springs Battlefield Visitor Center Witness
Printed address
— blank in the record
Operator
— blank in the record
NRHP / National Register
13000280 [9]
HMdb
— blank in the record
ARK
— blank in the record
Archive ID
— blank in the record
Register URL
— blank in the record
Coordinates
35.523556, -95.485119
Coordinate source
Oklahoma Historical Society Plan Your Visit [1]
Field
Verified value
Archives West ARK
— blank in the record
Official register listing URL
https://npgallery.nps.gov/AssetDetail/NRIS/13000280
Governing CFR/agency specification
— blank in the record
Official manager/operator
Oklahoma Historical Society [1]

See the recorded point on OpenStreetMap — the point as printed in the dossier's locator record. A pin is not a public entrance; the Before you go section above says where you may stand.

Blank fields are blank in the source dossier. Nothing is invented to fill them.

Honest gaps & disagreements

  • OHS gives Blunt’s early figures of 17 Union killed and 60 wounded and his estimates of 150 Confederates buried, 400 wounded, and 77 prisoners. Cooper’s own side is summarized by OHS as 134 killed or wounded and 47 prisoners. The revised Union return prints 13 killed and 62 wounded, aggregate 75, and notes the three river deaths in the table. The NPS battle database instead gives 77 Union and 134 Confederate estimated casualties. These are different sources and accounting categories. [4–6]
  • Visit Cherokee Nation gives approximately 9,000 men involved. Mvskoke Media reports approximately 3,000 Union and 6,000 Confederate. The NPS database's forces field lists 3,000 total and 0 Confederate, inconsistent with the report and database narrative. The zero field cannot establish that strength. [2–3,5–6]
  • The Mvskoke public account reports a Traditional Cultural Property designation and ongoing consultation. The underlying designation record was not retrieved. A Cherokee Phoenix search was blocked by its robots rules. This draft relies on Cherokee Nation’s published tourism history and the Muscogee Nation’s media account for the communities’ perspectives. [2–3]
  • The official reports were read in the OHS compilation transcribing the published U.S. War Department series. No signed manuscript or privately held soldier letter was verified. [5]

Save & note

Checking your sign-in…

Photo record (from the dossier)

Held candidate · post-battle landscape. Repository: Honey Springs Battlefield Collection, Gateway to Oklahoma History. Exact item: ark:/67531/metadc2305719. Browser pixels inspected: sepia open field, scattered trees and handwritten inscription. The image does not verify what lies beneath the ground. Its handwritten burial figure is an assertion and is excluded from routing. Rights basis: open reuse unverified. Credit if cleared: “Honey Springs Battlefield Collection, The Gateway to Oklahoma History, ark:/67531/metadc2305719, photographer unidentified, undated.” Photo Point absent. [7]

Excluded from then/now · illustration copy. The Gateway describes ark:/67531/metadc1595245 as a photograph of an illustration by James R. O’Neil. The source’s August 29, 1863 wording is distinct from the July 17 battle date. Copy photographer and current open reuse unverified. Credit as a held catalog record: “Oklahoma Historical Society Photograph Collection, The Gateway to Oklahoma History, ark:/67531/metadc1595245, artist James R. O’Neil, copy photographer unidentified.” Pixels for this candidate were not inspected. It supplies no battlefield camera standpoint. [4,8]

Records & sources

Published research — the record, with its gaps printed. Not yet field-proven.